Tree topping a recipe for disaster

Though a spin through nearly every neighborhood in the area shows that tree topping is a common practice, some local arborist can’t find a good reason for a person to have their trees topped. Once the top branches have been removed, the tree continues to grow in an unhealthy way, requiring even more attention by way of trimming and pruning, putting houses, cars, property and anyone who might pass below the tree in danger.

Because maintenance is frequent, and the health of the tree continues to decline, it will eventually die, not being able to thrive as untouched trees do.

Topping a tree removes much of the leaf coverage on the plant, hindering its ability to produce and process its food. This makes the tree go into its reserves, which negatively affects its health and this deterioration can be seen on the bark.

An unhealthy tree is also unable to repair its wounds, causing large scale decay of the tree because it can’t produce the energy to repair as needed. With the leaves removed, the tree is also often susceptible to sunburn on bark that is used to having coverage. This will weaken the bark and the tree, often resulting in dead branches that can be a danger.

Trying to produce itself more branches and leaves to improve its overall health, a tree will produce new shoots and branches, but they aren’t to the same strength and quality as the originals and also become hazardous. These shoots grow more rapidly than they do soundly and often need to be cut back more frequently than their predecessors. This is expensive maintenance, as well as increasing the chance of a dead limb falling on whatever is below.

We dont blame the property owners’ ignorance as much as the social pressure and pressure from tree toppers who are looking to make extra money.

The numbers just don’t add up in our estimation. Trees on a person’s property can account for around 10-15-percent of a property’s value, but people are often quick to pay someone $800 to service their trees. After years of the decay and decline of the tree, the overall cost to the property owner can be upward of $5,000. If you explain it like that, some people will understand.

City Arborist staff are very educated in this regard and exercises extreme caution in regards to tree topping. We are one of the most reputable and educated tree experts in bay area.

On Gardening: Don’t put off winter tree pruning

Today, we are about one-third of the way through winter, and well into the dormant period, which is the right time for winter pruning of trees.

Gardeners need always to be conscious of the change of seasons because it affects the growth cycles of our plants. Let’s review.

Winter begins on the shortest day of the year, called the winter solstice. In 2014, that day was Dec. 21.

The days gradually grow longer until day and night lengths are equal, marking the first day of spring. That phenomenon, called the vernal equinox, will occur in about 90 days, on March 15.

The cycle then continues for 90 more days. The days grow longer and the nights grow shorter until we have the longest day of the year, the summer solstice, which marks the beginning of summer.

Ninety days later, the day and night lengths again become equal and we will have the autumnal equinox, marking the first day of fall.

It is comforting in this troubled world that something of importance occurs on a predictable schedule.

So, this is the time for gardeners for winter pruning of trees.

Tree pruning involves practices that may be unfamiliar to some gardeners, encouraging them to avoid the work. The reality is that pruning is really not difficult, but it’s complicated enough that books have been written on the subject. The complexities arise when considering the growth patterns of different trees and the stylistic preferences of pruning specialists.

Without getting into all the ins and outs and ups and downs of tree pruning, consider the basics. First, winter pruning, which is done during dormancy, stimulates growth in the desired directions. Summer pruning, by contrast, done after spring growth is complete, directs or slows growth.

A third category, corrective pruning, could be done at any time, and should be done before seasonal pruning. The “Four D’s of Pruning” guide the removal of the following branches:

Dead >> If a branch looks dead, scratch the bark to look for a green layer. If it’s green, it’s still living. If it’s not green, remove it.

Diseased >> A sick branch can have various symptoms from disease or insect infestation. Between cuts, clean clippers with 10 percent bleach water.

Damaged >> Remove branches wounded or broken by storms or any other cause. They are unattractive and can foster diseases and insects.

Deranged >> The root meaning is “moved from orderly rows.” Remove suckers, water sprouts and branches that cross or rub other branches or point in the wrong direction.

A busy gardener might be tempted to skip this seasonal maintenance task, but trees, like everything else in the garden, grow better and look better when they are cared for regularly. Skipping seasonal pruning simply postpones the task, but doesn’t eliminate the need. Meanwhile, the tree doesn’t look its best.

Reach for your pruners!